Sink or Swim? Post-Sandy Waterfront Restoration

Scape Studio. Plan for Oyster Reefs in NY Harbor

As people blow dry the mold from basement walls and vacuum Sandy from corners and carpets, city activists gathered in a forum sponsored by the Municipal Art Society and Columbia University’s Center for Urban Real Estate, called &#8220Sink or Swim: Waterfront Restoration in a Post-Sandy Era.&#8221

Two of President Obama’s cabinet members spoke at the December 13 event, Secretary of the Interior, Ken Salazar and Secretary of Housing and Urban Development Shaun Donovan.

Donovan emphasized smart rebuilding, public and private partnerships and long-range thinking about the water’s edge. He seemed aware that the future would not look precisely the same, and said people should be prepared to reconsider the relationships between land and water in innovative ways in the coming age of dramatic climate change, saying that the plan should put us on the path of a more sustainable future. Applause greeted his definition of the relationship of localities and the Federal government: &#8220We don’t leave individual communities to pick up the pieces after a disaster: we lift up individual communities as a nation.&#8221

US Sec. of Housing &amp- Urban
Development’s Shaun Donovan

The panel that followed his comments included Kate Orff of the Scape Studio, whose work includes projects proposing artificial oyster reefs in the New York Harbor that could calm the impact of incoming wave surges. Her discussion was framed in response to various scenarios which could call for big infrastructure, like a barrier across the entrance to the harbor. But she was more interested in the sort of hybrid solutions that combined natural resources and habitat with  &#8220soft infrastructure.&#8221

These types of  proposals were displayed in a 2010 show at the Museum of Modern Art called &#8220Rising Currents.&#8221 Proposals included remaking wetlands as buffers between land and sea that would act as sponges to absorb water. Several of the projects use fabricated ecology to create slower water, paying attention to dunes, wetlands, reefs and islands. The landscape architects of the Scape Studio calls the artificial oyster reefs &#8220oyster-tecture&#8221 and touts the ability of the oysters to clean as well as calm the waters.

Eugenie Birch, an urban planner pointed out that New York City actually had many of the tools it needs already in hand to create effective responses. She called for integration of information in PlaNYC 2030, Environmental Impact Statements, Natural Hazards Mitigation Plans, Waterfront Revitalization Programs and Vision 2020 Report, and said the issue is information coordination, leadership and action.

Other panelists interpreted the Sandy experience as a challenge to rethink paradigms, and ensure that when plans are made they are implemented with an associated investment strategy.

Paul Farmer, head of American Planning Association and known for his work on Hurricane Katrina and Haiti, emphasized that water management to keep water in place is a day-to-day task, not an emergency response. He said that multiple defenses are more likely to succeed.

His thoughts were echoed by the Dutch Delta Commissioner for Flood Risk Management in the Netherlands, Jos Van Alphen. He outlined ways in which protection, planning, damage reduction, land use policy and disaster management provide layers of social policies that help the Dutch respond to nine million people living below flood levels. Van Alphen’s presentation showed how social planning had a daily impact, drew on a constant stream of investment and was revised and updated to respond to changes in science and environmental thinking.

Take a look at the YouTube videos from conference held at the Jewish Heritage Museum in Battery Park.

One thought on “Sink or Swim? Post-Sandy Waterfront Restoration

  • November 30, -0001 at 12:00 am

    I grow oysters in Greenport in conjunction with Cornell Cooperative Extension, Cedar Beach, Long Island NY. My oysters survived Sandy and show evidence of wild sets to ecosystem in the harbor. I believe that the restoration of oyster beds in and around the region would mitigate the damage of probable near future storms. I volunteer to assist in a practical way should this effort go forward–let me know.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.